We've borrowed others, but this is the best.
Bought this for use in a farmers' market, and we needed something that looked good, could be put up and taken down easily, but wasn't so heavy that one person couldn't move it. Yes, it does take two to put it up, but it is very easy, and comes down without difficulty. The second time we used it, it rained like crazy, but we were dry underneath. No leaks, no problems. The bag makes this even handier. It was so worth the extra money. We don't normally use the sides, but we have them in case we need them.
ProsVery substantially made. Feels like it will last longer than the others.
ConsMaybe a tad expensive, but well worth it since we won't need to replace it every year.